Just when we thought it couldn't get any worse, a Labor government is about to shred the vocational training system on the blades of the free market. Not only is the Victorian TAFE system the worst funded in the country, not only are its teachers on the lowest wages of any TAFE teachers in the country (and paid less than high school teachers), the Government is about to introduce changes which will kill off or seriously injure existing institutes and allow rampant profiteering by private corporations. Here are main "features":
- Double or triple fees paid by students
- Make government funding contestable by private corporations. This means that private providers can apply for, and receive, government funding to provide training.
- Remove limits on the numbers of places a training provider can offer
The issue of contestability is fraught with danger. As yet there's no indication of how providers are to set fees or even whether there will be limits set by the Government. Can you imagine if a private provider, who might otherwise charge $10000 for a fee-for-service place, got $7-8000 from the government and then still charged $5k?
One hopes it won't be so.
The last one has been little discussed. What most people don't know is that the Office of Tertiary Training and Education (now known by the fatuous and opaque title of Skills Victoria) put years of work into modelling the demands for skills in the employment market. Now even though my area -- sound production -- would be (and was) designated as a "low priority" course, it does make sense for the government to spend its education dollar wisely on training people for skills that are actually needed and in occupations where there are skills shortages.
Well, OTTE and the puppet Minister for Education got rolled by some arseholes in Premier and Cabinet. It is said that the then Department Secretary for OTTE was so insensed that she resigned.
So what's the wash-up? Well, since the government will now purchase as many places for students as we can enrol, maybe its not so bad. Except that it's inevitable that private providers will cherry-pick the cheap courses -- those for which only a classroom, a whiteboard and desks and chairs are required -- so established providers (TAFE institutes) will lose places.
The response at my institute, so I've heard, is to convert fee-for-service courses into "recurrently funded" courses (funded by the government). And since there's no limit on the numbers we can enrol, even in what was previously a low priority course, it's an easy way of keeping up the number of places and therefore the revenue. However, our Department is still expected to generate a high level of fee-for-service revenue even though we've lost more than half of it. So the net result is that everyone is trying to think up fee-for-service programs that can be offered.
I'm not having a go at my insitution. Converting fee-for-service places into recurrently funded places is actually a rational response to what's going to happen. But the net effect is that those of us "at the coalface" (to use a cliche beloved of politicians and public servants) are going to have to put in thousands of hours of unpaid overtime to develop new course with the meagre, and in some cases, non-existent resources that we have. And that's on top of the overtime we already do.
I would venture to say that there's probably not a single colleague who's not putting in at least one day a week extra -- even those of us who are on a 0.6 contract (three days a week) -- that we're not being paid for.
One has to wonder what the motivation is. Well, apparently the Federal Minister for Education would like to see a similar thing so I wouldn't be surprised if she planted the idea in the Premier's mind. But to throw out years of work and let the kids do whatever courses they want, regardless of whether there'll be a job for them at the end of it, and do it when the economy is tanking big time, is plain stupid.
But it's just one of a number of things that Premier Brumby is doing that no one wants... except a few small vested interests. Here are some others:
- Building a pipeline between the Goulburn River and Melbourne, effectively stealing water from the most degraded and fucked up river system in the country
- Building a desalination plant instead of regulating water saving and coming down hard on industrial wastrels
- Building more freeways instead of a reliable public transport system. It'd be really cool to get a comment on this blog from the PR guys at Dis-Connex. Hey, it doesn't matter what you say. No one believes you. Now go and get a real job.
The decisions have been made despite rational, well-argued opposition and there'll be no back-down. Because to reverse such decisions make you look weak. And Brumby doesn't want to look weak. He's just another bloke hung up about his masculinity who'll never admit his mistakes. This is exactly the macho bullshit evident in so many cultures, and in every totalitarian state, around the world that's got us where we are. Haven't you noticed? It's always the fucking men.
Brumby is no different to the leaders of China, Cuba or North Korea. He's having a mid-life crisis and has to show the world what a big man he is.